Sampling, Respiratory Protection and Fit Testing for Welding Fumes
As with other airborne contaminants, an effective approach combines risk assessment, appropriate engineering controls, exposure monitoring and, where required, correctly selected respiratory protective equipment (RPE). Monitoring and PPE do not replace the duty to eliminate or minimise exposure risks so far as is reasonably practicable.
Air Sampling for Compliance
A key step in assessing exposure is representative personal air sampling. Sampling can establish airborne contaminant concentrations in a worker’s breathing zone and support calculation of an eight-hour time-weighted average (TWA). Gravimetric sampling measures collected particulate mass; identifying and quantifying particular metals generally requires suitable laboratory analysis. Results can also help evaluate the performance of engineering controls, but a conventional air sample does not, by itself, demonstrate the protection achieved by a respirator.
A sampling pump such as the SKC AirChek Essential+ can draw air through a suitable collection medium positioned in the worker’s breathing zone. The pump, flow rate, sampler and analytical method must be selected for the target contaminant and the applicable sampling standard.
It is essential to choose the correct sampling medium and particle-size fraction for the substance being assessed. For example, the SKC IOM Sampler can be used for suitable inhalable particulate methods; a different sampler may be needed for respirable particulate exposure, and welding gases require separate methods. Expert occupational hygiene guidance may be necessary when multiple metal constituents are present.
Real-Time Aerosol Monitoring
To complement personal air sampling, real-time aerosol monitoring can be undertaken using an instrument such as the DustCanary Trend 420 real-time respirable dust monitor. Real-time readings can help identify concentration changes during particular tasks and illustrate the effect of ventilation or work practices. However, direct-reading aerosol instruments cannot identify individual metal constituents, and responses can be affected by particle size and composition. They therefore complement, rather than replace, substance-specific exposure sampling and laboratory analysis.
Respiratory Protective Equipment and Fit Testing
Personal protective equipment (PPE) is a lower-order control in the hierarchy of controls. Engineering measures and safe work practices should be considered first, with RPE providing an important additional layer of protection where residual welding-fume exposure remains.
Welding helmets fitted with powered air-purifying respirators (PAPR) are one RPE option for welders. These systems use a powered blower and suitable filters to supply filtered air to a compatible PAPR helmet. Protection depends on the equipment configuration, correct selection, use and maintenance.
PAPR systems may use tight-fitting or loose-fitting headtops. Tight-fitting respiratory facepieces require fit testing to confirm an adequate seal and users must be clean-shaven where the facepiece seals against the skin. Quantitative fit testing instrumentation such as the OHD Aerofit and Quantifit II should be used to test individuals in their RPE. Loose-fitting headtops generally do not require fit testing, but must still be correctly selected and used. Protection factors vary by equipment classification and configuration; loose-fitting PAPR should not automatically be described as providing a lower level of protection.
Businesses should be aware of the following standards relevant to the selection, use and fit testing of RPE:
- AS/NZS 1715:2009 ‘Selection, Use & Maintenance of Respiratory Protective Equipment (RPE)’
- AS/NZS 1716:2012 ‘Respiratory Protective Devices’
- AS/NZS ISO 16975.3:2023 ‘Fit Testing for Respiratory Protective Devices’
Ultimately, the appropriate RPE depends on the substances and concentrations involved, the controls already in place, the work being undertaken and the suitability of the equipment for the wearer. Fit testing, where required, is one part of a broader respiratory protection program.